Hey there, fellow DIY enthusiasts and jigsaw aficionados!
I know firsthand that a jigsaw is an essential piece of equipment in any workshop, whether you’re a seasoned pro or a weekend warrior. But the process of choosing the right type of jigsaw for your needs can be quite challenging, especially when you’re faced with the age-old question: corded or cordless?
That’s why I’ve put together this blog post to help you navigate the world of jigsaws, and make an informed decision between these two popular options.
We’ll dive into the key differences between corded and cordless jigsaws, explore the pros and cons of each, and discuss the types of projects and situations where one might be more suitable than the other.
So, grab a beer and let’s get started on our jigsaw journey!
Contents
Corded Jigsaws
How corded jigsaws work?
Corded jigsaws plug directly into an electrical outlet, drawing a constant supply of power to drive the motor. This continuous power source allows for uninterrupted operation without concerns about dwindling battery life.
Pros:
- Power and performance: In my experience, corded jigsaws typically deliver more power and maintain consistent performance compared to their cordless counterparts. This makes them ideal for tackling heavy-duty tasks or cutting through thicker materials like hardwoods and metal.
- Continuous operation: Thanks to their direct connection to an electrical outlet, corded jigsaws can run continuously without any downtime for battery charging or swapping.
- No need for battery replacement: Since corded jigsaws don’t depend on batteries, you won’t have to worry about battery life or the expense of purchasing replacements.
Cons
- Limited mobility: Being connected to an outlet can restrict your movement, which can be especially challenging when working in tight spaces, maneuvering around obstacles, or handling larger projects.
- Power outlet dependency: Corded jigsaws necessitate access to an electrical outlet, which may not always be available or convenient on job sites, outdoors, or in remote locations.
- Cord management: Managing a cord while working can sometimes be cumbersome, as it may get tangled, caught on objects, or create a tripping hazard.
What purpose is a corded jigsaw better for?
In my experience, corded jigsaws excel when used for heavy-duty tasks, or in situations where you’re working in a shop or home environment with readily available power outlets. They are also a practical choice for those who use their jigsaw infrequently, as they can remain idle for extended periods without any negative impact on their performance or reliability. Additionally, corded jigsaws can be a cost-effective option over time since you won’t need to invest in batteries and chargers.
Cordless Jigsaws
How do Cordless Jigsaws work?
Powered by rechargeable batteries, cordless jigsaws give you the freedom to move around without being confined to a power source, providing flexibility and convenience during your projects.
Pros
- Portability: One of the greatest advantages of cordless jigsaws is their portability. Their ability to function without a power outlet makes them perfect for job sites that lack power sources or projects that demand a lot of movement and maneuverability.
- Convenience and flexibility: With no cords to manage, cordless jigsaws deliver greater flexibility and ease of use, particularly in tight spaces or when executing intricate cuts. This freedom allows you to focus on your work without the hassle of cord management.
- Ideal for job sites without power outlets: For those who often work in remote locations or job sites where power outlets are scarce, a cordless jigsaw can be an invaluable tool in your arsenal.
Cons
- Limited battery life: One downside of cordless jigsaws is their reliance on batteries, which can limit operation time during extended use. To counter this, you may need to carry spare batteries or pause your work to recharge.
- Potential for reduced power compared to corded models: Cordless jigsaws may not always deliver the same level of power as their corded counterparts, which could impact performance when cutting through thicker or denser materials.
- Battery replacement costs: Over time, batteries will eventually need to be replaced, adding an extra cost to your overall investment.
What purpose is a cordless jigsaw better for?
Based on my experience, cordless jigsaws are well-suited for occasional jobs or scenarios where portability and flexibility outweigh raw power. They’re particularly useful for job sites without accessible power outlets or for users who require frequent movement and adaptability during their work. Additionally, cordless jigsaws can be a solid choice for light to medium-duty tasks that don’t demand continuous, high-powered cutting.
Factors to Consider When Choosing a Jigsaw
Nature of your projects (DIY or professional)
It’s essential to determine whether you’ll be using your jigsaw mainly for DIY projects at home or for professional, heavy-duty tasks. Corded models tend to be more suitable for demanding jobs, while cordless models provide the flexibility and portability needed for lighter tasks or on-the-go work.
Workspace availability and power outlets
Assess the power outlet situation in your workspace. If you have easy access to outlets, a corded jigsaw might be the most practical choice. On the other hand, if outlets are limited or you often work in remote locations, a cordless model could be the ideal solution.
Frequency of use
Your usage pattern also plays a significant role in your decision. If you use your jigsaw frequently or on a daily basis, a cordless model may offer more convenience and freedom. However, for those who use their jigsaw less frequently, a corded model is often more dependable and cost-effective over time.
Long-term costs and maintenance
Cordless jigsaws can have higher initial costs due to the need for batteries and chargers. Additionally, battery replacement costs should also be considered. Weigh these factors against your budget and the benefits of each type to determine the most suitable option for your needs.
Personal preferences and experiences
Take into account your personal preferences and past experiences with corded and cordless tools. For some people, the convenience of cordless tools outweighs their drawbacks, while others prefer the reliability and longevity of corded models. Reflect on what has worked best for you in the past to help guide your decision.
Corded vs Cordless Jigsaw Comparison Table
To help you visualize the differences between corded and cordless jigsaws, I’ve put together a comparison table below:
| Feature | Corded Jigsaw | Cordless Jigsaw |
|---|---|---|
| Power Source | Electrical Outlet | Rechargeable Battery |
| Power & Consistency | Generally Higher | Potentially Lower |
| Mobility | Limited | Increased |
| Continuous Use | Yes | Dependent on Battery |
| Battery Replacement | Not Applicable | Required |
| Best for | Heavy-Duty Tasks | Portability & Flexibility |
Corded and Cordless Jigsaws from Different Brands
Which is better: Ryobi cordless jigsaw or corded?
Both Ryobi cordless and corded jigsaws have their unique advantages. The cordless model offers excellent portability and flexibility, making it perfect for on-the-go projects. On the other hand, the corded version provides more consistent power, which is ideal for heavy-duty tasks or cutting through thicker materials. Ultimately, your choice will depend on your specific needs and priorities.
Bosch jigsaw: cordless vs corded
Bosch is renowned for its high-quality tools, and their jigsaws are no exception. Their corded jigsaw delivers superior power and performance, making it a top choice for demanding projects. However, if you prioritize portability and flexibility, the Bosch cordless jigsaw is a fantastic option, offering convenience without compromising too much on performance.
DeWalt jigsaw: cordless or corded
My Top Picks for Corded and Cordless Jigsaws
In choosing my top picks for corded and cordless jigsaws, I considered factors such as power, performance, ease of use, durability, and overall value for the price. I also took into account my personal experience with these tools and feedback from fellow DIYers and professionals.
| Feature/Model | Bosch JS470E | DeWalt DW331K | Makita 4350FCT | DeWalt DCS331B | Milwaukee 2737-20 | Makita XVJ03Z |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Type | Corded | Corded | Corded | Cordless | Cordless | Cordless |
| Power | 7.0 Amp | 6.5 Amp | 6.3 Amp | 20V Max | M18 FUEL | 18V LXT |
| Strokes per Minute (SPM) | 500 – 3,100 | 500 – 3,100 | 800 – 2,800 | 0 – 3,000 | 0 – 3,500 | 0 – 2,600 |
| Variable Speed | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Orbital Action | 4 Orbital Settings | 4 Orbital Settings | 3 Orbital Settings | 4 Orbital Settings | 4 Orbital Settings | 3 Orbital Settings |
| Tool-less Blade Change | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| Bevel Capacity | 45° Left/Right | 45° Left/Right | 45° Left/Right | 45° Left/Right | 45° Left/Right | 45° Left/Right |
| Dust Blower | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| LED Light | No | No | Yes | No | Yes | No |
| Weight | 5.9 lbs | 6.4 lbs | 5.7 lbs | 5.4 lbs (tool only) | 5.3 lbs (tool only) | 6.4 lbs (tool only) |
| Price Range | $$ | $$ | $$ | $$$ (tool only) | $$$ (tool only) | $$$ (tool only) |
Top 3 corded jigsaws
- Bosch JS470E Top-Handle Jigsaw – This powerful jigsaw offers smooth, precise cuts and a comfortable grip. Its robust design ensures durability and long-lasting performance, making it a top choice for both DIYers and professionals.
- DeWalt DW331K Top-Handle Jigsaw – With its reliable performance and user-friendly features, the DeWalt DW331K is a fantastic option for those looking for a versatile and dependable corded jigsaw. Its variable speed control and orbital action make it suitable for various materials and applications.
- Makita 4350FCT Top-Handle Jigsaw with LED Light – This Makita jigsaw stands out for its built-in LED light, which illuminates your work area for better visibility. Its powerful motor, variable speed control, and toolless blade change system make it a convenient and efficient choice.
Top 3 cordless jigsaws
- DeWalt DCS334B 20V Max Jigsaw (tool only) – The DeWalt DCS334B offers the convenience of a cordless tool without compromising on performance. Its 20V Max battery system provides ample power, while the all-metal lever-action keyless blade change makes it easy to switch between tasks.
- Milwaukee 2737-20 M18 FUEL D-Handle Jigsaw (tool only) – Known for its power and durability, the Milwaukee M18 FUEL jigsaw is perfect for those who need a reliable cordless option. Its brushless motor and REDLITHIUM battery technology ensure long-lasting performance and run time.
- Makita XVJ03Z 18V LXT Lithium-Ion Cordless Jigsaw (tool only) – With its efficient brushless motor and compatibility with Makita’s 18V LXT battery platform, the XVJ03Z delivers excellent performance in a portable package. Its toolless blade change and variable speed control make it a breeze to use, even for beginners.
Conclusion
Corded jigsaws typically offer more power and consistent performance, with the advantage of continuous operation as long as they’re plugged into an outlet. However, they can be limiting in terms of mobility and may require more attention to cord management. Cordless jigsaws, on the other hand, provide greater portability and flexibility, making them ideal for job sites without power outlets or projects that require frequent movement. Their main drawbacks are limited battery life and potentially reduced power compared to corded models.
Ultimately, the decision between corded and cordless jigsaws comes down to your specific needs, preferences, and work environment. Take into account factors such as your project types, workspace availability, frequency of use, and budget when making your choice. I hope this comparison has helped you better understand the differences between corded and cordless jigsaws and will guide you in selecting the perfect tool for your projects. Happy cutting!